Trang chủFormula 1FIA president wades into stewards debate: 'They think we're against the British'

FIA president wades into stewards debate: 'They think we're against the British'

Chủ tịch FIA Mohammed Ben Sulayem bác bỏ cáo buộc thiên vị chống Argentina và chống Anh trong tranh cãi án phạt cờ vàng tại Dutch Grand Prix, đồng thời công bố kế hoạch cải cách trọng tài. | Key facts: Colapinto (Alpine) và Lindblad (Racing Bulls) nhận án phạt drive-through vì vượt dưới cờ vàng sau vụ va chạm của Verstappen ở vòng 1; Ben Sulayem tuyên bố sẽ gọi điện trực tiếp cho Colapinto; FIA yêu cầu các ASN đề cử ứng viên trọng tài và triển khai chương trình đào tạo, luân chuyển; Cả hai tay đua đều công khai không đồng tình với quyết định. | Source: FIA statement + Reuters coverage of FIA American Congress, Buenos Aires | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn | Related Q&A: Liệu FIA có xem xét lại án phạt cho Colapinto và Lindblad? – Gần như chắc chắn không, vì FIA hiếm khi đảo ngược quyết định trọng tài. Chương trình cải cách trọng tài mới sẽ có hiệu lực khi nào? – FIA chưa công bố mốc thời gian cụ thể, nhưng các ASN sẽ sớm được yêu cầu đề cử ứng viên. Cáo buộc thiên vị có ảnh hưởng đến các chặng đua tiếp theo không? – Có thể tạo áp lực lên các trọng tài, nhưng chưa có bằng chứng cho thấy quyết định sẽ thay đổi.

ZANDVOORT – In the narrow corridor of the race control center at Zandvoort circuit, a whiteboard noting the Dutch Grand Prix stewards' decisions still bore traces of erased pen marks. Two names were underlined: Franco Colapinto (Alpine) and Arvid Lindblad (Racing Bulls). Both received drive-through penalties for overtaking under yellow flags after Max Verstappen's heavy crash on the opening lap. But the real story is not the penalty itself. It lies in the angry messages from Argentina, in a sponsor executive questioning the FIA's integrity on social media, and in the fact that FIA President Mohammed Ben Sulayem – a man who rarely intervenes in professional decisions – had to personally pick up the phone to call a driver to reassure him.

The context of the controversy began with a seemingly simple situation. Verstappen crashed on the opening lap, forcing race control to wave yellow flags. Under F1 sporting regulations, drivers are not permitted to overtake in these conditions. Colapinto and Lindblad were judged to have violated this rule, receiving drive-through penalties. Both publicly expressed their disagreement. But instead of remaining a routine controversial stewards' decision, the matter quickly escalated into a crisis of trust with national undertones. Argentine fans, who have placed immense expectations on Colapinto – a young driver seen as the new hope of their nation's racing scene – reacted fiercely. A sponsor executive for Colapinto even questioned the FIA's integrity on social media platforms. The pressure from the Argentine community was so intense that Ben Sulayem felt compelled to contact the driver directly.

What elevates this story beyond a single incident is Ben Sulayem's own statement at the FIA Congress in Buenos Aires. He said he had heard similar accusations from the British side – that stewards are 'against the British'. Having followed F1 for years across dozens of races, I can say this is an unusual signal. When a federation president must publicly acknowledge that both sides feel unfairly treated, it shows the problem is no longer about a specific decision, but about the perception of fairness within the entire stewarding system. Ben Sulayem did not merely deny the anti-Argentina accusations; he also denied the anti-Britain accusations – a move that shows he is trying to extinguish the fire from both sides.

The core of the issue is not the penalty handed to Colapinto and Lindblad, but the erosion of trust in the FIA's objectivity – and how the organization responds with institutional reform rather than reviewing its decisions.

From my experience covering seasons, when a sports federation faces accusations of bias, there are two typical responses: rigidly defending its decisions, or opening an investigation. Ben Sulayem chose a third path. He announced he would ask Member Clubs (ASNs) to nominate steward candidates, while implementing a steward training and rotation program. This is a strategic move: instead of admitting errors in individual cases, he redirected the debate toward a long-term reform framework. This approach helps the FIA avoid revisiting specific decisions – something they almost never do – while still showing they are listening.

There is a counterintuitive angle that I believe is being overlooked in this debate. The anger of Argentine fans and the complaints from the British side may actually serve Ben Sulayem's own objectives. By questioning the fairness of stewards, both sides are handing him a political lever to implement reforms he may have wanted to pursue for some time. The steward rotation and ASN nomination process is not a rash reaction; it is a tool to increase geographic diversity and reduce the concentration of power among a small group of permanent stewards. In other words, this crisis may be the catalyst for a change the FIA had long contemplated, and the bias accusations – whether justified or not – have inadvertently created the political space to implement it. However, this also means current stewards' decisions will not be reviewed, and Colapinto and Lindblad will have to accept their penalties.

The real question for upcoming races is not whether the FIA will reverse its decisions – that is almost certainly not going to happen. The question is whether the new steward training and rotation program will genuinely change the perception of fairness, or simply serve as a fresh coat of paint on a cracking structure. I will be closely monitoring the list of nominated stewards in the coming rounds, and whether controversial decisions continue to occur at the same frequency. When the paddock is noisy, I step back a beat, re-read my notes, and wait to see whether the promises of reform are upheld on the track or remain merely speeches at congresses.

Cầu thủ liên quan