When the Crowd Appoints Itself Referee: A Discipline Lesson from Santos Laguna and Puebla
**Core answer**: Santos Laguna đăng video dùng bài "Color Esperanza" và bị người hâm mộ phản ứng, vì cho rằng CLB hưởng lợi từ lựa chọn nội dung mà Puebla từng bị xử lý. Không cơ quan quản lý nào có thẩm quyền; tiền lệ Puebla định hình toàn bộ áp lực. **Key facts**: - Santos Laguna đang có chuỗi 3 trận thắng liên tiếp tại Liga MX tại thời điểm bài đăng gây tranh cãi. - Puebla trước đó đã xóa bài đăng cùng bài hát, xin lỗi và chấm dứt hợp đồng với quản lý cộng đồng. - Người hâm mộ dẫn lại tiền lệ Puebla để đặt câu hỏi về tính nhất quán giữa hai CLB. - FIFA, CONCACAF, FMF và Liga MX đều không có thẩm quyền điều chỉnh lựa chọn nội dung mạng xã hội của CLB. - Tài liệu nguồn ghi hai vụ việc xảy ra "trong những hoàn cảnh khác nhau"; phép so sánh do người hâm mộ tạo ra. **Source attribution**: Nguồn: bài phân tích chuyên sâu giai đoạn 2 về bài viết "Santos Laguna desata polémica con video en redes sociales" (Liga MX). Tài liệu nguồn không ghi ngày xuất bản. **Related Q&A**: Q: Vì sao người hâm mộ Santos Laguna phản ứng với bài đăng? A: Vì họ cho rằng CLB đang dùng một nội dung mà Puebla từng bị xử lý, tạo cảm giác về tiêu chuẩn kép. Q: Cơ quan nào có thể xử lý vụ việc này? A: Không cơ quan quản lý bóng đá nào có thẩm quyền; lớp pháp lý duy nhất liên quan là luật lao động. Q: Tiền lệ Puebla ảnh hưởng thế nào đến quyết định của Santos Laguna? A: Nó tạo ra một mức án tham chiếu mà người hâm mộ dùng để đòi hỏi phản ứng tương tự, dù không có quy định nào bắt buộc.
Within hours of Santos Laguna posting a video on the club's social media page, the comment most repeated beneath the post did not mention the three consecutive wins the team had just recorded. It was a short question: "Won't they fire this community manager?"

Every red card is a verdict written many plays earlier. The same applies here. The card that a section of Santos Laguna supporters are holding up was not drawn during a match. It was written months ago, in another city, in a post by another club. The person who receives it is a communications staffer who has never touched a ball in any match.
I have followed disciplinary controversies long enough to know that most verdicts in football do not begin where people assume. They begin with a precedent.
Liga MX is a league in which the community manager role carries far more public weight than is commonly assumed. Supporters treat a club's official account as a semi-official voice, and when that voice falls out of step, they react to it the way they react to a sporting decision. The role appears in no tactical diagram, yet it is present in every communications crisis the league produces.
Before the Santos Laguna episode, Puebla had published content using "Color Esperanza" — the Diego Torres song associated with a message of hope in difficult periods. The supporter reaction was strong enough that the club deleted the post, issued an apology, and terminated the contract of its community manager.
Santos Laguna repeated that musical choice. The reaction was fast, and it did not stop at criticising a song. It moved straight to the question of punishment. The article itself notes that the two episodes occurred "under different circumstances" — an important caveat, because the comparison between Puebla and Santos Laguna was constructed by supporters, not established by any authority with jurisdiction.
The only on-pitch fact this story provides is Santos Laguna's run of three consecutive wins. Three matches is far too small a sample to say anything about a trend. But it is enough to answer a more important question: where the team stood on the pitch at the exact moment the post caused controversy.
The charge sheet is not in the content of the post. It is in the Puebla precedent. This is the point most coverage of the episode skips. Supporters are not objecting to a harmless song. They are objecting to an inconsistency, and they state it in a very specific question: why is this club permitted to do what another club was once punished for? That question is not about music. It is about standards.
This is where the story becomes interesting through the eyes of someone who works in discipline. No body — FIFA, CONCACAF, the Mexican Football Federation, or the Liga MX organising committee — has jurisdiction over a song choice. No rule has been broken. The only legal layer touching the episode is labour law, and the source material does not say whether the termination at Puebla was contested. When there is no law, the noise of the stands becomes the law.
I once spent a season measuring exactly this mechanism. In 2026, when the K League played in empty stadiums, I analysed 171 matches and found that yellow cards fell 18.5% compared with the 2026 season. My conclusion then was that crowd pressure directly affects referees' tolerance thresholds. The stadium was empty, but discipline still sat in the stands — it simply sat more quietly.
The Santos Laguna episode is the inverted version of that finding. Here there is no law to apply, so there is no referee to come under pressure. Instead, the stands appoint themselves referee. And unlike a referee holding a rulebook, the stands need cite no clause and need explain no verdict. Data is never sent off — but when there is no data, the verdict defaults to whoever types loudest.
The cost, here, is allocated in a striking way. The Puebla precedent shows that punishment in club communications episodes is always paid by the person at the lowest rung of the production chain: the post is deleted, an apology is issued, and a staffer loses their job. The punishment is designed to be cheap. A community manager is not on the transfer list, carries no significant release fee, and affects neither the wage bill nor financial compliance indicators. For a club, cutting a communications position is the lowest-cost crisis response among all available options.
That is why I consider the Puebla precedent more important than this specific episode. It establishes a template of response. Once supporters have seen that outcome a single time, they possess a measuring stick for their demands the second time. The precedent functions as a reference sentence, and in a league with Apertura and Clausura phases, the memory of it does not fade before the next season begins.
Sporting form also shapes how the episode is handled. Three consecutive wins will not save a communications staffer, but they do prevent a club-level crisis. When results are good, the sporting department has no incentive to burn political capital defending a communications position. No one in the coaching staff or the squad is drawn into this story. Risk is pushed entirely onto one person, and that person stands alone.
I have written before that to understand a league, you should read the disciplinary record rather than the league table. In Liga MX, the disciplinary record for this episode sits in the comment section. It has no signatory, no case number, no appeal window. But it carries force.
In risk classification terms, this is a purely communications event. There is no financial risk, no regulatory risk, and sporting risk is close to zero. Reputational risk sits at medium to medium-high, but the news cycle for social-media controversies is very short. What lasts longer is the memory of the precedent.
This leads to a professional consequence few discuss. After two episodes involving the same song, what is produced is not a league regulation but an internal approval workflow. Liga MX's content standards are being written by its own supporters, and the clubs are merely reacting to them. It is a very expensive way to make law, because it always pays the price with a specific individual.
Now to the counterintuitive part. The natural reflex for Santos Laguna's leadership is to compare with Puebla and do the same thing: delete the post, apologise, possibly terminate the contract. That handling looks consistent. But it does not fix the inconsistency — it legitimises it.
If Santos Laguna dismisses its community manager simply because the Puebla precedent did so, the club confirms an implicit principle: punishment is decided by the volume of reaction, not by a written standard. The injustice supporters are denouncing does not lie between two clubs. It lies between written law and unwritten practice.
One further point is obscured by this comparison. "Color Esperanza" is a song about hope in adversity. Santos Laguna posted it while the team was winning three straight. Supporters read the post through the lens of the Puebla episode, so they saw the duplication, not the nuance. The intent of the person who posted it is not considered — and in a trial with no statute, intent is almost never considered.
I do not charge anyone; I simply follow the traces they leave on the pitch. In this case, the traces are not on the grass. They are in a comment thread.
What needs answering is not whether Santos Laguna dismisses a communications staffer. It is whether Liga MX clubs will write a standard before the next comment thread writes one for them. If another club posts that same song tomorrow, who will be the one issuing the verdict?

