Trang chủInternational FootballPeter Schmeichel Calls to Scrap VAR After the Manchester Derby: A Protocol Failure or a Broken System?
Peter Schmeichel Calls to Scrap VAR After the Manchester Derby: A Protocol Failure or a Broken System?
Trả lời nhanh: Tổ VAR đã không đề nghị trọng tài xem lại màn hình trong tình huống dẫn tới bàn thắng của Erling Haaland ở derby Manchester, và cơ quan quản lý trọng tài giải Ngoại hạng Anh sau đó thừa nhận có sai sót trong phán đoán. Điểm hỏng nằm ở ngưỡng can thiệp của giao thức, không nằm ở dữ liệu hình ảnh. Sự kiện chính: - Manchester City thắng 1-0 tại Old Trafford và ghi bàn khi đã chơi thiếu người từ giữa hiệp một. - Peter Schmeichel, cựu thủ môn với 292 lần khoác áo Manchester United, kêu gọi chấm dứt VAR. - Cơ quan quản lý trọng tài thừa nhận VAR lẽ ra phải đề nghị trọng tài xem lại màn hình. - Luật 11 của IFAB gồm ba nhánh: can thiệp vào bóng, can thiệp vào đối phương, hưởng lợi từ vị trí việt vị. - VAR được áp dụng tại giải Ngoại hạng Anh từ mùa giải 2019-20. Nguồn: bản tin của hãng thông tấn PA cùng các phát ngôn của cơ quan quản lý trọng tài giải Ngoại hạng Anh, công bố ngày 15 tháng 9 năm 2025. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Hỏi đáp liên quan: Hỏi: VAR được đưa vào giải Ngoại hạng Anh từ khi nào? Đáp: Từ mùa giải 2019-20. Hỏi: Vì sao bàn thắng của Haaland vẫn được công nhận? Đáp: Vì tổ VAR xác định Haaland ở vị trí hợp lệ và cầu thủ ở vị trí việt vị không chạm bóng. Hỏi: Điểm mấu chốt của tranh cãi nằm ở đâu? Đáp: Ở việc đánh giá cầu thủ việt vị có can thiệp vào đối phương hay không, và ở ngưỡng đề nghị trọng tài xem lại màn hình.
In the 60th minute at Old Trafford, the ball came in from the left flank, and at the far post Erling Haaland only had to meet it on the right beat. The net rippled. But almost nobody dared celebrate fully. The stands rose and then froze, tens of thousands of eyes turning to the big screen, waiting for the red lines to sweep across the frame. I was sitting in front of a screen in Hai Phong, close to 11 p.m. local time, and the only thing I did for the next two minutes was time it. A memorable Manchester derby, a fine finish, and in the middle of it a procedure left hanging. When the referee awarded the goal, I did not record the emotion. I recorded the silence.
The goal belonged to Haaland, from Josko Gvardiol's cross on the left. Manchester City played a man down from midway through the first half, after Phil Foden's red card, and left Old Trafford with a 1-0 win. Those facts appeared in every report. What kept the story alive for a week sat somewhere else.
Peter Schmeichel called VAR an annoyance and said it should be ended. His context deserves restating: he made 292 appearances for Manchester United, was the goalkeeper of a golden generation in the 1990s, and his voice carries weight with this club's supporters that a neutral commentator simply does not have. Gary Neville, his former teammate, agreed in milder terms but still called the situation baffling. Micah Richards also voiced confusion. Three men, three angles, one emotional conclusion: the technology is taking away more than it gives.
The foundation for the debate is not purely emotional. England's refereeing body publicly admitted an error of judgment and confirmed the video assistant should have recommended an on-field review. The Premier League Match Centre explained that the VAR determined Haaland was in a legal position and that the player in an offside position did not touch the ball. These two statements do not contradict each other on the facts. They contradict each other on the intervention threshold.
VAR entered the Premier League in the 2026-20 season. Five seasons on, the argument still circles one old question: when is a situation clear and obvious enough for the video team to step in. The original report came via the national news agency PA, and the way it was handled shows this stopped being a single club's business. It became a matter of league governance.
IFAB's Law 11 has three branches. A player in an offside position only commits an offence when involved in active play: interfering with the ball, interfering with an opponent, or gaining an advantage from that position. The second branch, interfering with an opponent, is where everything tangles.
The line that the player did not touch the ball answers the first branch. It does not answer the second. A player standing in an offside position, not touching the ball, but blocking the goalkeeper's line of sight or forcing a defender to handle the situation differently, can still be judged to have interfered with an opponent. This is football's long-standing grey zone, and it is not a grey zone created by technology. Technology merely makes it visible, slower, and more painful.
What stands out is that the refereeing body's admission does not deny the underlying situation. Haaland's position is not disputed. What is disputed is that the VAR failed to weigh how seriously the other player's presence affected Manchester United's ability to defend. In other words, the fault sits at the protocol-execution step, in the question of whether the threshold for recommending an on-field review was met, not in the video evidence. The frame was right. The reading of the frame was wrong.
Strip away the media shell and the rest of the match still deserves analysis. Manchester United played more than 60 minutes with a man advantage, at home, and scored nothing. That is an attacking-efficiency problem, not a technology problem. The fact that almost nobody mentioned that number over the past week says a great deal about how public attention is allocated.
For City, Haaland's finish fitted a familiar template: movement to the far post, occupying position ahead of the defender, a one-touch finish. It came from a left-sided defender, Gvardiol, pushing high and crossing, meaning it came from organised build-up rather than a random transition. A man down, City still held a defensive structure tight enough to protect a one-goal lead for over half an hour. The original report supplied no process data such as expected goals, successful pressing counts or possession share, so any deeper conclusion about the match has to pause here.
Numbers are only topsoil; I dig deeper for the groundwater. In this case, the topsoil was churned up further by a questionable data error. Some accounts circulating on social media attributed the offside player's name to Enzo Fernandez, who is a Chelsea player and was nowhere near Old Trafford that day. A wrong name slipped into the news stream and was then reshared as a verified detail. When the pitch is empty, I listen to the data. It lies more than I once thought. And it lies faster than a cross travels.
The call to scrap VAR is the loudest voice, but it aims at the wrong wound. Remove the technology and the identical offside situation would be decided by an assistant referee in a split second, under the same reading of the law, except with no frame to check against. The root problem, covering the clear-and-obvious threshold and the reading of the interfering-with-an-opponent branch, would survive intact. Technology did not create that grey zone; it only made it more expensive in media terms.
Belief only has value if it passes the qualifying round of evidence. As things stand, the case for VAR being broken rests on a single incident in a single match, plus a trail of follow-on headlines. A sample size of one. I once erred in a similar way: at the 2026 World Cup I underrated Morocco because I looked only at possession share, and then had to write a three-part self-rebuttal after rewatching their five matches. The lesson is not never to conclude. The lesson is to know how many observations you actually hold.
One more point needs saying plainly: a speaker's reputation does not substitute for data. Schmeichel made 292 appearances for United, but on-pitch fame is not a certificate in VAR protocol. When a legend says scrap it, that line carries enormous emotional weight for his club's fans, and very little weight in answering the technical question of which step the VAR got wrong.
One match does not make a talent, but it illuminates exactly the spot that needs excavating. Here, the spot that needs excavating is not VAR's fate. It is the quality of video-referee training, and the transparency of the internal grading process after every admitted error.
What I am waiting for in the coming weeks is not another apology. I am waiting to see whether the refereeing body publishes its internal review findings, whether IFAB clarifies the interfering-with-an-opponent branch of Law 11, and whether semi-automated offside technology is accelerated. If VAR is scrapped after one admitted error, then next time, when an assistant referee makes a similar mistake, what exactly will we argue with?
Bài đề xuất
Mbappé Watches PSG Beat Barcelona 4-2: What He Did Not Say Matters More Than What He Did2026-10-23
Karim López and His Opening 8 Minutes with the Memphis Grizzlies: A Defensive Signal in the Race for an NBA Roster Spot2026-10-08
Transfer Window Filter: Reading Rumors Through a Referee's Eye2026-09-14
Group A ASEAN Cup 2026: Indonesia Must Beat Bangladesh, but Malaysia Holds Its Own Fate2026-10-01
Borneo vs Persija: The 8-Game Curse, Shin Tae-yong, and the Psychological Puzzle at Stadion Segiri2026-09-05
Reading the Gaps in the Transfer Market2026-10-14
The Transfer Dossier That Came Back Empty: Reading the Silence2026-09-16
Vietnamese Football Through Nine Dimensions of Deep Analysis: An Assessment Framework, Data Gaps and a Re-verification Roadmap2026-10-07
Bài đề xuất
Indonesia and Thailand: A Transition Game That Exposed Southeast Asian Football's Control Deficit2026-10-06
Turkey 1-4 Italy: Zeki Çelik and the Silence After the Storm at Home2026-09-30
Atletico Fans Jeer Alvarez and Display 'Ceuta' Banner Targeting Mbappe and Vinicius: Cause for Concern Before Madrid Derby2026-09-21
Seven Goals in an Empty Stadium: England's Pitch Geometry and Croatia's Structural Collapse2026-10-04
Two Sets of Books in Vietnamese Football: 47 Sponsorship Contracts and Twelve Missing Payments2026-10-16
January at Old Trafford: When Fear Becomes a Transfer Invoice2026-10-10
Ghoulam and PSG's 'Pre-emptive Steal': When Fabian Ruiz Became a Pawn Between Paris and Madrid2026-09-26
82% and One Man: Bursaspor Are Carrying a Whole Season on Iheanacho's Shoulders2026-10-14
Bài đề xuất
Traffic Brawl on Avenida Revolución: A Viral Video in Mexico City and a Parallel Probe Targeting Traffic Police2026-09-25
Hüseyin Özkök and the Galatasaray–Fenerbahçe Derby: One Quote, Two Outcomes, Zero Data2026-10-25
Solari and the Pumas Academy: 1,184 Compliant Minutes, One Debut, and What the Scoreboard Never Tells2026-10-01
The Night Football's Data Machine Returned Zero2026-09-16
Allen Bailey dies at 37: the man who held the door for the Kansas City Chiefs locker room2026-10-23
Zidane's Nations League Debut: France Travel to Turkey With a Defence Still Needing Repair2026-09-26
Manchester United and Bruno Fernandes: A One-Year Option, Not a Sad Ending2026-10-20
Bài đề xuất
Uğurcan Çakır's 87th-Minute Red Card: When a Goalkeeper Steps Outside His Safe Zone2026-09-26
Arda Guler Leads La Liga in Chances Created: Real Madrid Locking Down a €90m Asset Until 20312026-09-14
Rivas Manuhutu and Indonesia's Left-Back Gamble Before the 2027 Asian Cup2026-10-17
FA Cup: KSI, Barry Hearn and the Ownership Equation at the Bottom of English Football2026-10-03
NEC and the Free Mitchel Bakker: Patching the Left Flank With a Fitness Gamble2026-09-19
Data Void: When Deep Football Analysis Lacks a Foundation2026-09-11
The Cursed Minutes in Jakarta: A 9-2 Win and the Crack Nobody Saw2026-10-04
The Silent Rhythm of Aaron Rodgers: When Podcasts Echo Louder Than Huddles2026-09-12
