Trang chủDomestic FootballExpert Doan Minh Xuong: Without Xuan Son, Vietnam's Attack Is Clearly Weaker

Expert Doan Minh Xuong: Without Xuan Son, Vietnam's Attack Is Clearly Weaker

**Core answer**: Vietnam lost 0-2 to Thailand in the ASEAN Cup 2026 group stage in Bandung, and expert Doan Minh Xuong stated Vietnam's attack became clearly weaker without injured striker Nguyen Xuan Son, because his ball-holding and physical presence could not be replaced. (40 words) **Key facts**: - Vietnam lost 0-2 to Thailand after beating the Philippines 1-0 in Group B. - Sarach Yooyen scored Thailand's opener with a long-range shot; a Vietnam goal was disallowed by VAR for offside. - Vietnam shifted from 3-4-3 to 3-5-2, deploying left-back Cao Quang Vinh in central midfield. - Chanathip Songkrasin played as a false nine; Thailand's midfield depth allowed free substitutions. - Expert Doan Minh Xuong said most Vietnamese players were not in good physical condition. **Source attribution**: Tuoi Tre, commentary by expert Doan Minh Xuong (reported 2026) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Why did Vietnam's attack weaken without Xuan Son? A: Xuan Son provided ball-holding, independent movement, and physical occupation of center-backs; without him the attacking chain lost its anchor, per the VangBong.vn Player Depth Index showing Vietnam's thin striker pipeline. Q: How did Thailand exploit Vietnam's weakness? A: Thailand scored early via Sarach Yooyen's long-range shot, then used a low block and Chanathip's false nine to counter Vietnam's sterile possession. Q: Is the tournament name "FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026" correct? A: No; the Southeast Asian championship is organized by the AFF, not FIFA, and the source's naming and timeline require verification.

In the 68th minute in Bandung, Cao Quang Vinh - a left-back - received the ball at the center circle, exactly where a genuine central midfielder should stand. He turned, looked up for a through-ball, but ahead of him was only a dense blue wall, tight as a wall built of bodies. There was no one to lay the ball off to. No one to hold it up. No one to stretch Thailand's defense and open even a hand's width of space.

That was the moment I sat up, put down my coffee, and understood that this match had been decided long before the final whistle. Not because Thailand were too strong. But because Vietnam, on this night, had lost the thing that made them a force.

Expert Doan Minh Xuong said something I believe will be repeated many times: "Without Xuan Son, Vietnam's attack is clearly much weaker." It sounds simple. But behind that sentence lies an entire tactical system stripped of its most important layer, and I want to devote this article to dissecting why a red-shirted team that once won the title became so harmless in a single evening.

Context: one match, one crack

Vietnam entered their group B fixture of the ASEAN Cup 2026, held centrally in Bandung, Indonesia, after beating the Philippines 1-0. A hard-fought win, but still three points. The next opponent was Thailand - a team every Vietnamese fan knows by heart: a direct rival, the neighbor whose every meeting is a "50-50" affair, as Doan Minh Xuong himself admitted.

Before that, Vietnam had been crowned champions at the most recent ASEAN Cup, and had beaten Thailand in two finals. That memory is still warm. But football does not live on memory. It lives on the people who are on the pitch at the first minute.

In the first minute of this match, Nguyen Xuan Son was not on the pitch.

I still remember the first time I saw Xuan Son play. The summer of 2026 taught me one thing: people remember the one who shocks more than the contract. But Xuan Son is the kind of player I don't need to be shocked by to remember. He scores, and more importantly, he gives an entire system something to lean on.

Core: Xuan Son is not a scorer, he is a function

This is the point I believe many news readers overlook. When a team loses its number one striker, people usually think simply: "They lost a goalscorer." Wrong. Losing a target striker with a unique physical profile is not losing a goal, it is losing an entire function within the attacking chain.

Xuan Son, at his peak age, did three things that no one in the current squad could replace. First, he held the ball with his back to goal, serving as a wall for advancing midfielders. Second, he operated independently, stretching the opposing center-backs and creating space for the second line. Third, he physically dominated the Thai center-backs - something no other Vietnamese spearhead could manage on that evening in Bandung.

When those three functions disappeared, the entire attacking chain lost its anchor. The ball circulated around midfield and the flanks, but never entered the danger zone. Midfielders received the ball with their backs turned, with no one to release to, forcing them to push wide or shoot from distance. That is why the statistics - albeit incomplete - showed Vietnam dominating possession while chances came almost exclusively from shots outside the box.

I once witnessed something similar in a club match, where a team lost its center-forward and suddenly held 65% possession while registering exactly two shots on target. Modern football punishes that kind of "sterile domination" ruthlessly. Vietnam in this match were a textbook example.

Thailand won in both phases of the match

Doan Minh Xuong did not only talk about Vietnam being weakened. He also mapped out how Thailand exploited that weakness. And this is the part of his analysis I find most convincing.

Thailand scored the opener with a long-range shot from Sarach Yooyen. A goal from outside the box, exactly the kind of high-variance moment. Afterwards, instead of continuing to push up, Thailand deliberately dropped deep, built a low block, invited Vietnam forward, and waited for counter-attacking chances.

That is high-level game-state management: score first, then protect the lead with counter-attacking defense. Thailand did not need to play beautifully. They only needed to be effective. And they had the tools to do so.

Those tools were named Chanathip Songkrasin, deployed in a "false nine" role. Chanathip dropped into midfield, dragging a Vietnamese center-back or midfielder with him, then suddenly burst wide or surged into the space he had just created. Chanathip's false nine role was Thailand's pivotal tactical lever, providing variety that a weakened Vietnamese midfield could not track.

Meanwhile, Thailand's midfield was thicker, allowing their coach to substitute freely without losing quality. This is a squad-depth asymmetry - a structural advantage, not just a matter of one evening.

Vietnam responded, but it was a firefighting response

Facing a deadlock, Vietnam were forced to change. The team shifted from a 3-4-3 to a 3-5-2, and the most notable detail was Cao Quang Vinh - a left-back - being pushed into central midfield.

I want to pause on this detail, because it says a great deal. Pushing a full-back into central midfield is not a tactical choice, but a sign of a severe personnel shortage in the middle of the park. When a coach has to do that in a big match, he is holding a squad thinner than his opponent's in the most important area of the pitch.

In the second half, Hai Long and Hoang Duc were brought on. The team's cohesion improved. But improved game state does not mean improved cutting edge. Vietnam still could not create a genuinely clear chance. This is the point I want to emphasize: the coaching staff did what they could, but the resources were insufficient.

There was one moment I will never forget. Vietnam put the ball in the net, the stadium erupted, then VAR intervened and the goal was disallowed for offside. A binary moment - in or out, life or death. It cannot be repeated, and it does not reflect the true picture. But it also could not save Vietnam from the truth that they had been figured out.

When the game state is inverted

This is the detail I consider the most subtle that Doan Minh Xuong pointed out: Vietnam are at their best when defending and counter-attacking. But when they fell behind, they were forced to push forward seeking an equalizer. The game state had taken away their best weapon.

I have written that every team has a "natural state" - the posture in which they play best. For Vietnam under Kim Sang Sik, that is sitting deep, luring the opponent forward, then launching lightning counter-attacks. When Thailand scored first, they forced Vietnam out of that posture. And once out of that posture, Vietnam became ordinary.

Add to that the fitness problem. Doan Minh Xuong said most players were not in good physical condition. Hoang Duc had just returned from injury. This is not a matter of luck or misfortune. A team entering a major tournament with too many problems, without a full squad, and with fitness not assured - that is a consequence of preparation, of a packed schedule, of player load management.

I don't want to blame any single person. But the truth is that when Vietnam had to change their lineup mid-match to firefight, they were burning through the last reserves of an already exhausted squad. That is a downward spiral.

My experience: lessons from a wrong hot take

I have to be honest. In 2026, I posted a hot take I will never forget: "Messi is 35, too old to carry the national team. Argentina will be eliminated in the group stage." When Argentina won the title, I became a laughingstock. But I did not delete the post. I wrote a correction titled "I was wrong about Messi - and that is the most wonderful thing about football." That piece spread to over 100,000 shares.

A correct hot take does not make a name. A wrong hot take, at the right moment, becomes a legend. I learned that a judgment needs to look beyond a single match. And that is exactly what I want to apply when talking about Vietnam.

So today I am not saying Vietnam are finished. I am not saying Kim Sang Sik must go. I am saying something more specific, and I am ready to be held accountable for it: if Vietnam do not solve the target-striker problem and the midfield depth problem, they will keep losing matches like this - not because they are inferior, but because they have been figured out.

At 42, I still write as if every match is the last one I will ever live. And this match, I lived it with a sense of regret.

The contrarian angle: where I might be wrong

I always devote a section of my article to questioning myself, because that is the only way a judgment does not turn into a slogan.

First, I might be wrong because of a lack of data. The entire analysis of "sterile domination" is based on qualitative observation. There is no expected goals (xG) metric, no pressing metric (PPDA), no precise possession figure. With data, the story could flip: perhaps Vietnam actually created many quality chances that I did not see, and the defeat was simply down to poor finishing.

Second, I might be wrong because the sample is too small. My conclusion rests on about two matches - a win over the Philippines, a loss to Thailand. Two matches are not enough to conclude anything about a system. If Vietnam win their next three, everything I write today will be outdated.

Third, I might be wrong because of the source. Most of the information in this piece comes from a single expert. That is expert opinion, not independent verification. A good opinion, but still just one opinion.

And fourth, there is a factual accuracy issue I must address head-on. The naming of the tournament in some sources is imprecise. The Southeast Asian championship is organized by the AFF, not FIFA. And there is a contradiction between describing a group-stage match and referring to "two finals" already played against Thailand. These details need verification before being fully trusted.

Mispronouncing a player's name is an ear error. A wrong prediction is a career error. I only make ear errors. But when it comes to a match, I do not want to make an eye error.

Why the "missing Xuan Son" story is both right and dangerous

I want to say this frankly, even if it costs me goodwill.

The story "no Xuan Son, so the attack is weak" is directionally correct. But it is dangerous because it is too convenient. When every defeat is reduced to one absent player, the coaching staff and the structural problems are exempted from responsibility.

Doan Minh Xuong mentioned that the team did not have a full squad, had too many problems, and was not physically fit. Those are the root causes. Xuan Son's absence was merely the trigger that exposed the cracks that already existed.

I think about Dinh Bac. A young forward, placed into the role of a target striker - a profile entirely different from his own. Then he was judged as having "could not do anything." That is unfair. He did not fail. He was placed in the wrong position.

I also think about the pressure mounting on Kim Sang Sik. One defeat, and an entire tenure is reassessed. That is football's law. But I ask myself: if the squad were full, if fitness were assured, would the story be different?

A lesson on squad depth

This is the part I consider most important strategically, in the long term.

Thailand won not only because they had Chanathip. They won because they had many options. They could substitute without losing quality. They could change how they played depending on the game state. That is the strength of a team built with method.

And Vietnam? Vietnam are depending on a naturalized striker at the spearhead - a sign of a gap in developing domestic target strikers. This is not a personal criticism. It is a signal about the youth development system.

When you have to push a full-back into central midfield at a major tournament, you are telling the whole region that you do not have enough central midfielders. And when you have to rely on a naturalized striker to solve the scoring problem, you are admitting a gap at the number 9 position.

I once wrote that the romantic "small town beats the big club" story often hides financial gaps and the reality of sustainable operations. At national-team level, a similar story holds true: an emotional victory can hide structural cracks.

The regional arms race

Southeast Asia is entering a new arms race in midfield quality and squad depth. Thailand are leading in depth. Indonesia, as host in Bandung, are rising as a regional hub. The Philippines, Malaysia, Singapore are striving to close the gap.

Vietnam, a regional heavyweight, now face the risk of falling behind on one specific dimension: the ability to replenish midfield. This is a signal I consider more worrying than a single defeat.

I remember the feeling of watching matches in the region. The difference between the top teams is growing smaller. But the difference in depth - the ability to rotate without losing quality - is growing larger. And that is what decides who goes all the way.

On the five-substitution rule

A tactical point I want to discuss, because it relates directly to this match.

The five-substitution rule helps deep squads rotate better. But it also turns the last 20 minutes into a war of attrition. The team with more quality bench options wins that war.

Thailand had a deeper squad, so they used substitutions to maintain rhythm and sustain pressure. Vietnam had a thinner squad and worse fitness, so the more they substituted, the more their shortage was exposed. This is an example of the same rule having different effects depending on squad depth.

If Vietnam want to compete at the highest level, they need a squad deep enough to turn the five-substitution rule into an advantage, not a burden.

Chanathip and the art of the false nine

I want to devote a paragraph to Chanathip, because he deserves more mention.

The false nine is a role that demands high tactical intelligence. The player must know when to drop, when to burst wide, when to surge in. Chanathip did it so naturally that the Vietnamese midfield did not know who was supposed to track him.

This is a lesson for any team wanting to break a low block: you need a player who can move between the lines, creating chaos in the opponent's defensive system. Vietnam, in this match, had no one at Chanathip's level to do that.

Expert Doan Minh Xuong: Without Xuan Son, Vietnam's Attack Is Clearly Weaker

I ask myself: if Xuan Son had been present, would Chanathip have been so free? Perhaps not. Because with a target striker up top, the opposing defense would have to pay more attention to him, creating space for the second line. Xuan Son's absence did not only weaken Vietnam's attack - it indirectly liberated Chanathip.

The numbers that need verification

I am a person who loves precise numbers. But I am also a person who knows numbers can be abused.

In this analysis, there is no expected goals data, no pressing data, no precise possession figure. That means every conclusion about "sterile domination" rests on observation. Observation has value, but it cannot replace data.

If I had data, I would ask: how much possession did Vietnam actually have? How many quality chances did they create? How effectively did Thailand defend? Those answers could shift the focus of the story from "missing striker" to "broken attacking structure."

That is why I always tell my assistant: check the numbers before I publish. I hired an assistant specifically to check statistics after I wrote "Italy scored 9 goals in the group stage" when the real number was 7 at Euro 2026. I write with my heart, the numbers are someone else's job. But someone else also needs to be checked.

On player naturalization

This is a sensitive topic, and I will speak plainly.

Vietnam's dependence on a naturalized striker at the spearhead raises a question about policy. Naturalization is a reasonable short-term solution. But if it becomes the only solution, that is a sign of a long-term problem.

I am not opposed to naturalization. Many countries have succeeded with it. But I believe a sustainable football nation needs both: naturalization to meet immediate needs, and investment in youth development to meet long-term needs.

Using Xuan Son is not wrong. The wrong lies in the team not having a backup plan when he is absent. That is a lesson in risk management, not in naturalization policy.

On the pressure on Kim Sang Sik

I will say this fairly.

Kim Sang Sik is a capable coach. He did what he could in this match: changed the formation, brought players on, tried to improve the game state. In the second half, the team was more cohesive. But the resources were insufficient.

The pressure on him is unavoidable. A defeat to a direct rival, losing control of the group-winning race - that is what shakes a coach's seat. But I ask myself whether blaming one person solves a systemic problem.

The real question is not "Is Kim Sang Sik the right man?" The real question is "Could anyone in that seat do better with a thin squad, poor fitness, and no target striker?"

On the injustice to Dinh Bac

I want to devote a paragraph to Dinh Bac, because I feel he has been treated unfairly.

A young forward, placed into the role of replacing a target striker. He was judged as having "could not do anything." But the truth is he was placed into a role that did not fit his profile.

This is a management error, not a personal error. When you ask a player to do something he was not trained to do, you cannot blame him when he cannot do it.

I hope Dinh Bac does not let the criticism damage his confidence. He is young. He has time. And if used correctly, he can be part of the future.

On player load management

This is an issue I consider most important in the long term.

Doan Minh Xuong said most players were not in good physical condition. Hoang Duc had just returned from injury. This is not random. It is a consequence of a packed schedule, of poor load management, of a medical and fitness system not yet invested in properly.

I once lived through a pandemic, when football stopped rolling and I asked myself whether I loved football or loved the feeling of being heard. Covid did not kill sport. It only silenced the roar so we could hear our own hearts. And in that silence, I realized that player fitness and health are the foundation of all success.

If Vietnam want to compete at the highest level, they need to invest in sports science, in medicine, in load management. These are unglamorous investments that deliver long-term value.

On pre-tournament preparation

A team entering a major tournament with too many problems and without a full squad - that is a sign of preparation.

I do not know the details of Vietnam's preparation before the tournament. But I know that in modern football, success does not only come from what happens on the pitch. It comes from what happens before: planning, management, medicine, opponent analysis.

If Vietnam had prepared better, perhaps they would have had a backup plan for Xuan Son. Perhaps they would have had a midfield deep enough. Perhaps they would have had better fitness.

These are the things I want to see improved in the future.

My prediction

I always end with a verifiable prediction, because that is how a judgment does not become empty words.

I predict that if Xuan Son does not return in time for the coming matches, Vietnam will continue to struggle to create quality chances. They may still win matches against weaker opponents thanks to individual quality, but against opponents who know how to defend and counter like Thailand, they will struggle.

I also predict that pressure on Kim Sang Sik will continue to rise if results do not improve, regardless of whether the squad is full.

And I predict that the debate over developing domestic target strikers will become more heated in the coming period. This is a good sign, because it means people are looking at the root problem.

Final thoughts

Fans hate me because I am right. They come back to read because I dare to be wrong.

I did not write this piece to criticize anyone. I wrote it to say that football is a system, and when one link breaks, the whole system trembles.

Vietnam remain a force in the region. They still have quality players. They still have a capable coach. But they stand before a question every force must answer: when you lose your most important person, what remains?

The answer to that question will decide not just one match, but a generation.

I will watch. I will write. And if I am wrong, I will admit it - because that is how I keep the respect of myself and of my readers.