Trang chủDomestic FootballThe 104th Minute and the Fall That Cannot Be Erased: VAR, Sterling, and Two Words Called 'Clear'

The 104th Minute and the Fall That Cannot Be Erased: VAR, Sterling, and Two Words Called 'Clear'

Core answer: Cú ngã của Raheem Sterling ở phút 104 trận bán kết Euro 2020 vẫn gây tranh cãi vì luật bóng đá chưa định lượng được ngưỡng va chạm vai; theo chuẩn 'clear and obvious error', trọng tài Makkelie được phép giữ quyết định gốc. Key facts: - 7 tháng 7 năm 2021: Anh thắng Đan Mạch 2-1 sau hiệp phụ tại Wembley, bán kết Euro 2020. - Phút 104: Sterling ngã sau va chạm với Mæhle, trọng tài Makkelie chỉ tay phạt đền, không xem màn hình biên. - Giao thức VAR chỉ cho phép can thiệp khi có 'clear and obvious error' trong bốn nhóm tình huống. - Premier League mùa 2020/2021 ghi nhận kỷ lục 40 quả phạt đền, phần lớn do điều luật thủ bóng mới của IFAB. - IFAB đã sửa điều luật thủ bóng vào tháng 3 năm 2021 sau phản ứng từ các giải đấu. Source: Phân tích của Samuel Hernandez, dữ liệu Opta và giao thức IFAB | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Tại sao VAR không đảo quyết định phạt đền ở phút 104? A: Vì cú chạm vai không đạt ngưỡng 'clear and obvious error' theo giao thức IFAB. Q: Điều luật thủ bóng nào khiến Premier League lập kỷ lục 40 quả phạt đền mùa 2020/2021? A: Bản sửa đổi của IFAB coi mọi chạm tay dẫn đến bàn thắng là phạm lỗi bất kể ý định. Q: VuaBong.vn có dữ liệu phân tích nào hỗ trợ? A: Chỉ số phân tích trọng tài và dữ liệu đội hình của VangBong.vn cung cấp bối cảnh bổ sung cho các tranh cãi VAR.

The 104th minute, Wembley, 7 July 2026. Raheem Sterling burst into the Danish penalty area, brushed shoulders with Joakim Mæhle and went down. Dutch referee Danny Makkelie, without ever taking his eyes off the turf, pointed straight at the spot. No pitchside monitor. No earpiece. Not a single review. Harry Kane struck, Kasper Schmeichel saved, Kane scored the rebound, and England walked into their first ever European Championship final. One nation celebrated. Another called it a robbery. Twelve months earlier I sat in a newsroom in Nagoya, my Japanese colleagues unable to understand why a first-year writer had argued with the entire floor over a penalty awarded half a world away. I do not watch matches through the eyes of the spectator, but through the eyes of the man being judged by spectators. What I tried to explain then, and what I still try to explain four years later, sits inside four English words few Vietnamese fans bother to notice: clear and obvious error. This is not decorative phrasing. It is the foundation stone of the entire VAR protocol, the line between when technology may intervene and when it must stay silent. And in the 104th minute at Wembley, by the letter of the law, Makkelie did precisely what the protocol permits: he held his original decision, because that shoulder contact was not clear enough to be treated as an obvious error. What isolated me in that meeting was not defending Makkelie. It was saying that the very law the world was cursing was behaving exactly as written. To understand why a fall in the 104th minute caused more argument than an entire World Cup qualifying round, return to the beginning. VAR was not born to reveal the truth. It was born to correct errors the referee cannot see with the naked eye. The gap between those two ambitions looks small, but it determines the entire operating philosophy. IFAB, the game's lawmaker, did not design VAR as an independent investigative body. They designed it as a support tool, an insurance layer placed on top of a human's original decision. The referee remains the supreme judge. VAR may only speak in four categories: goals, penalties, direct red cards, and mistaken identity. Outside those four, no matter how wrong, VAR must stay mute. At the 2026 World Cup, VAR appeared for the first time on football's biggest stage. In France against Australia in Group C, in the 58th minute, Uruguayan referee Andrés Cunha became the first in World Cup history to overturn a decision after checking the pitchside monitor, awarding Antoine Griezmann a penalty. I watched that match in Nagoya, aged twenty, a sociology student, and wrote a three-thousand-word piece solely to record the sequence of the consultation. Not to say right or wrong. But to understand where power was moving from and to. Before 2026, the referee alone held authority on the pitch. After 2026, that authority is shared with a sealed room in an operations centre, where invisible people control the angles. But there is a paradox few notice. The more technology, the less referees dare to decide. This is what I observed across more than a thousand VAR matches I have documented. When a defender handles in the box, in 2026 a referee would blow on instinct. In 2026, the referee waits. Waits for what? For VAR confirmation. And if VAR does not confirm, the ball keeps rolling. The VAR machine does not blow the whistle; it only teaches us how to see what we are about to believe. The modern referee is no longer the man who decides in a split second, but the man waiting for a signal in his earpiece before daring to blow. Return to Sterling's fall. There are three layers to peel: physics, law, and psychology. Physics first. In football, shoulder-to-shoulder contact is a legal part of the game, defined as using the shoulder to challenge for the ball when both players are moving toward it. The condition is that both must be oriented toward the ball, and the force must not cross a dangerous threshold. In the 104th minute, Sterling had pushed the ball past Mæhle and was already leaning forward. Mæhle placed his shoulder into Sterling's back. The margin between the two bodies was tiny, short of a full shoulder charge. But that tiny margin occurred exactly as Sterling had lost his balance. This is the crux: the referee does not judge the contact, the referee judges the consequence of the contact. Law layer. Law 12 states that a player who falls because of an unlawful impediment earns a direct free kick, meaning a penalty inside the box. But the definition of 'unlawful' depends on the referee's subjective assessment. And this is where I want to linger longest, because almost the entire social-media argument ignores it. There is no mathematical definition of 'a push strong enough to cause a fall'. No unit of force has been issued by IFAB. No Newton threshold distinguishes a legal shoulder-contact from an offence. Meanwhile, in other areas of life, law tends to quantify: the alcohol limit is 0.05%, the speed limit is 60km/h, the weight limit is 3.5 tonnes. In football, the law still says 'if the referee feels'. Psychology, the last and hardest layer. The 104th minute of a Euro semi-final is not the 104th minute of a friendly. Both teams had each run over twelve kilometres. Adrenaline is many times normal. Referee Makkelie, after more than an hour with the whistle, was in the state sports psychologists call decision fatigue. Research by Apesteguia and Palacios-Huerta published in 2026 in the Journal of Political Economy showed referees tend to award decisions favouring the home team more when the stands are full and loud. Wembley that night held more than sixty thousand, almost all England fans. This is not an accusation. It is a variable any scientific model of refereeing must include. What haunted me for years was not whether that penalty was correct. It was that football created a near-total surveillance system, then voluntarily blindfolded itself with two words: 'clear'. Imagine a court with cameras recording the entire crime scene, experts analysing frames at one twenty-fifth of a second, then declaring the evidence usable only if the error is overwhelmingly obvious. That is exactly how VAR operates. Clear and obvious — the way sports law names its own helplessness. The phrase does not make the law more transparent. It grants the referee a shield to protect the original decision, even when the machine in the operations centre has already seen what the naked eye missed. There is another moment I want to place beside the 104th minute at Wembley, to show the problem is systemic, not personal. The 2026/2026 Premier League season set a record of forty penalties, the highest of any season since the league was founded in 2026. Most came from the new handball rule IFAB issued, stating that any hand contact leading to a goal or a goal-scoring opportunity is an offence, regardless of intent. Within that same season, the Premier League twice wrote to IFAB asking for relaxation, and IFAB amended the rule in March 2026, then amended it again. The pandemic handball law was a logic accident whose designers never noticed. They modelled the human arm as a rigid metal bar in space, not as a body part that moves with momentum, loses balance, absorbs impacts. During the long COVID break, when global football froze and I did not know if I still had a job, I downloaded the entire Opta dataset on the forty-seven handball incidents penalised in the Premier League and coded each by three variables: the angle of contact, the arm's position relative to the body's axis, and the distance from hand to ball. The result surprised me. Referees showed a stronger tendency to penalise when the arm deviated from what I provisionally called the 'natural body silhouette' — that is, when the arm extended beyond the outline of the torso at rest. But IFAB has never defined 'natural body silhouette' in the text of the law. Referees were adjudicating by a standard that does not exist on paper. I presented this at an online refereeing seminar, and it became the bridge that brought me into the international refereeing research community. That finding led to a counter-intuitive conclusion: the problem is not that the law is too strict, but that it is too vague while technology is too precise. When you have a camera capturing hand contact at half a millimetre, you will find hundreds of handball incidents in a season. But if the law does not specify which arm position is an offence, then finding those hundreds only produces hundreds of arguments, not justice. Technology here does not create truth. It merely amplifies ambiguity a hundredfold. And when ambiguity is magnified to the level of individual frames, fans stop arguing about the law. They begin to suspect motive. This brings me to the observation I consider most important in years of work. Fans do not oppose VAR. They oppose inconsistency. The same handball, whistled this week, ignored the next. The same contact, a penalty in one match, play-on in another. This inconsistency does not come from referees being incompetent. It comes from the law granting them too much interpretive power while providing too few tools to interpret consistently. A system whose outcome depends on who holds the whistle is an unfinished system, however modern its supporting technology. There is a deeper paradox I want to place on the table. VAR was designed to protect referees from criticism, yet the real-world result is the exact opposite. Before VAR, a wrong decision was seen as part of the game, an occupational accident everyone accepted with mild regret. After VAR, every wrong decision becomes a deliberate sin. Because fans know a sealed room has seen everything, and if it still does not correct, then either it lacks competence or it has intent. Technology stripped referees of the right to be innocently wrong. That is a price few anticipated. I have covered eight Olympic Games, eight World Cups, and many editions of the Giro d'Italia and the Tour de France. Across all those sports, I have never seen one with a technical surveillance system as complex as football's, nor one leaving so many arguments about consistency. Cycling has photo finishes, positioning chips, finish-line cameras. But no one argues over whether the winner truly won. In football, we have argued over one shoulder contact in the 104th minute for four years, still without an answer both sides accept. That is a sign the problem is not technology, but how we define an offence. So if I sat in an IFAB meeting, what would I propose? First, standardise contact thresholds into quantified levels using reference videos, as the International Cricket Council does with ball-tracking technology. Second, make the entire consultation transparent by publicly releasing the audio between referee and VAR, as some competitions have begun trialling. Third, and most importantly, change the naming. 'Clear and obvious' is a technically meaningless phrase, because when we say 'clear' we mean the judge's perception, not data. To have a consistently applicable standard, IFAB must define error at the level of millimetres of contact and frames of time, not at the level of 'whether the referee feels it is clear'. On another front, what worries me most is not a wrong decision at a Euros. It is how technology can be abused in future. As VAR intervenes ever deeper into subjective situations, it sets a precedent for a trend: every decision can be reviewed, every decision can be recorded, and eventually every emotion on the pitch is frozen by a selectively chosen frame. Football is a sport of unbroken flows. If we turn it into a set of still images, we have killed what makes it beautiful. Looking back at Sterling's fall after four years, I have not changed my view. By the letter of the current law, Makkelie was right. But 'right by the law' does not equal 'right'. That is the tragedy of a legal system written to protect the game's continuity, then exposed to its very core by technology. That fall was not Sterling's fault, nor Makkelie's. It was the fault of those who wrote a rulebook believing human perception could become a universal standard, then placed above it a machine that does not know what perception is. The direction I believe in is this. In the coming decade, we will see a shift from 'VAR reviewing humans' to 'humans interpreting VAR'. Referees will no longer sit waiting for an earpiece signal. They will be the ones posing questions to the machine, rather than being questioned by it. Their role will shift from decision-maker to standard-designer. And when that happens, what we need to standardise is not cameras but the language of the law. Because every argument about VAR is ultimately not an argument about technology. It is an argument about what we want football to look like under a microscope. When a child in Nagoya, my second home, watches the 104th minute online in 2026, they will ask why that fall still sparks argument. The answer will not be 'because the referee was wrong' or 'because the referee was right'. The answer is: because four years on, that law still has not defined a shoulder challenge. And as long as the law confesses its helplessness with the word 'clear', football will keep living with wounds that cannot be erased.