Trang chủFormula 1Red Bull's second seat: Mekies credited with ending the 'curse', but the data has yet to speak
Red Bull's second seat: Mekies credited with ending the 'curse', but the data has yet to speak
core_answer: Laurent Mekies đang được ca ngợi vì đã giúp Isack Hadjar ổn định ghế thứ hai Red Bull, nhưng nhận định này chỉ dựa trên một kết quả P3 tại Baku và một nguồn ý kiến từ Will Buxton, chưa đủ để xác nhận xu hướng.
key_facts: Hadjar đạt P3 tại Azerbaijan sau gần hai tháng nghỉ vì chấn thương cổ tay.; Red Bull xoay vòng ba tay đua trong 2025: Perez, Lawson và Tsunoda.; Mekies thay thế thế hệ quản lý Horner-Marko từ mùa 2026.; Will Buxton cho rằng văn hóa an toàn của Mekies đã phá lời nguyền.; Chưa có dữ liệu so sánh Hadjar với Verstappen để xác nhận.
source: Nguồn: Phân tích gốc của Samuel Garcia | Ngày xuất bản: 15/05/2026
related_qa: q: Liệu Hadjar có giữ được ghế đến hết mùa 2026?, a: Chưa thể khẳng định; cần theo dõi khoảng cách tốc độ với Verstappen trong ba đến năm chặng tới.; q: Vì sao Red Bull liên tục thay tay đua thứ hai?, a: Xe được phát triển quanh Verstappen khiến ghế thứ hai trở thành bài toán phù hợp giữa xe và người lái.; q: Perez sẽ đua cho đội nào trong mùa 2026?, a: Perez gia nhập Cadillac, đội đua mới do Mỹ hậu thuẫn.
At Baku, Isack Hadjar stood on the podium with P3, just weeks after returning from a wrist injury that kept him out of the cockpit for nearly two months. In athletics, a runner returning from injury is usually judged over three straight races, not one breakthrough. But in Formula 1, that single result at a street circuit has been labelled something much bigger: Laurent Mekies has ended Red Bull's second-seat curse. Based on my years of watching F1, one podium has never been enough to clear five layers of verification.
The upheaval began clearly in 2026. Sergio Perez was dropped after a disappointing run, Liam Lawson lasted only two rounds before being sent back to Racing Bulls, and Yuki Tsunoda was promoted as a stopgap for the rest of the season. In 2026, Red Bull chose academy product Isack Hadjar, but a wrist injury nearly derailed the plan. His return P3 in Azerbaijan was a positive signal, and new team principal Laurent Mekies became the centre of the story. Will Buxton, on the Up To Speed podcast, credits Mekies with a modern management philosophy: a happy and safe space, replacing the “diamonds forged under pressure” ethos of the Horner-Marko generation.
The “curse” narrative has a real foundation. Since around 2026, the seat alongside four-time champion Max Verstappen has repeatedly swallowed drivers or spat them out quickly. But calling it a curse may miss a structural cause: Red Bull's car is built around Verstappen's extreme preferences, with a very pointy front end and aggressive rotation on entry. A second driver inheriting that car often lacks not raw pace but car-driver fit. This is the blind spot Buxton's analysis does not address: is the result down to a new management culture, or to Hadjar adapting better to a car designed for one man?
The current data set has a single sample. Hadjar's P3 at Baku, a low-grip street track where qualifying position and Safety Car timing matter more than anywhere else, is a strong but circuit-specific outcome. The tactical machine does not run on emotion; it runs on information, and the only information we have is a finishing position, with no lap-time data, no qualifying gap to Verstappen.
The biggest weakness of the “Mekies ended the curse” thesis is that it rests on one opinion source and one result. Buxton is a veteran journalist, but his view is analysis, not a team leak. The cultural-change story sounds plausible, especially since Red Bull genuinely shifted authority from the Horner-Marko era to Mekies. But an analytical framework only matures after reality refutes it. We have seen many teams declared to have “turned the corner” after a few races, only to slip back.
The contrarian angle is hiding inside the praise. A “safe” environment can dull competitive urgency. Historically, long-term champion teams blend pressure and support; they do not remove pressure entirely. If Hadjar is shielded too much, the first time he must sacrifice himself for Verstappen's title interests will be the real test of the new culture.
The Red Bull-Racing Bulls ecosystem is working as designed. Hadjar moved up, Lawson moved down, and Sergio Perez found a new home at Cadillac. Cadillac signing an experienced driver like Perez suggests the new US-backed entrant values stability over rookie risk. Don't ask who is playing well; ask which system the game favours. Red Bull locked Hadjar to a new contract early, partly to block a rival poach and partly to signal the second seat is solved. But the driver market runs on repeated results, not promises.
The lesson from my Kanté mistake is a reminder I do not want to forget. In 2026, I published a prediction with insufficiently verified data and readers caught the error immediately. I deleted the piece, built a five-step verification process, and never release numbers without cross-checking. That process is why I approach the “curse is over” claim with caution. When a story carries this much emotional pull, the writer's job is to verify, not to cheer.
The biggest risk Red Bull faces lies outside the seat story. The 2026 power-unit regulation reset will reshuffle the order, and the Red Bull Ford Powertrains programme is a bigger variable than any cultural shift. If reliability fails, a stable second seat means little. In football, I learned that transfers are not addition; they are forecasting. Choosing a second driver in F1 is the same: a long-term forecast, not an instant answer from one race.
For Hadjar, the new contract is a clear signal that Red Bull believes in him. But believing in a talent is not confirming a trend. His wrist injury is a recurrence risk, and a return after nearly two months away is often judged against a low bar. Real progress will be measured by qualifying and race gaps to Verstappen over the next three to five rounds, not by one podium finish.
For now, the right move is to let the season answer. If Hadjar sustains his form, Mekies' cultural story gains data. If he fades, the media will quickly find the “curse returns” headline with as little evidence as today's optimism. In sport, the one thing that never lies is time and the gap between two cars of the same colour. Let those numbers lead, before we crown anyone the curse-breaker. And if the season contradicts the optimism, I will update my model willingly, because an analytical framework is never finished; it just becomes less wrong.
Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
When Telemetry Returns Zero: The Silent Data Gap Reshaping F1 Analysis2026-10-26
The Tribute Helmet Cannot Mask the Disaster: Aston Martin and the Data Problem at Monza2026-09-04
Antonelli, Mercedes and the 2026 Season: Looking Back from 2036 Through Ripened Data2026-09-19
Red Bull's 2026 Season: Valuing a Winless Team and the Narrow Door Called Madring2026-09-11
World Cup 2026: 12 Groups, 104 Matches, and a Rupture Point That Sits After the Group Stage2026-09-14
Mercedes, the Secret Code and Antonelli's VSC Call: A Win Programmed on Sunday Morning2026-09-19
Piastri and the Tow Bar in Baku: 0.838 Seconds Redraws the Race Map2026-09-26
Schumacher 2026: A Complete Picture of the Season That Reshaped F1 History Through Netflix Documentary Lens2026-09-05
Bài đề xuất
RB22's stint-phase aero degradation: Red Bull patch the foundation while McLaren, Ferrari and Mercedes add performance2026-09-18
Three Sources, One Datapoint: Reading the F1 Transfer Window When Noise Beats Signal2026-09-16
Hanoi 2026: When the Ball Rolled Through the Storm2026-09-03
ADUO 2026: FIA Grants Engine Upgrade Allowances on an Unpublished Index2026-10-19
Dissolution Is Not the End: The Hidden Cost Equation from F1 Team Collapses2026-09-04
Briatore accuses FIA judge of McLaren bias: Off-track drama hotter than the Italian GP2026-09-05
McLaren to bring rotating rear wing H-Wing to Monza, expects breakthrough at Italian GP2026-09-03
Gasly shocks with pole position, five drivers face grid penalties at Monza2026-09-07
Bài đề xuất
Speed of Judgment: When F1 Must Relearn How to Blow Its Own Whistle2026-09-21
RB22's stint-phase aero degradation: Red Bull patch the foundation while McLaren, Ferrari and Mercedes add performance2026-09-18
Isack Hadjar in Baku: A Podium After Injury and the Team-Order Equation2026-09-28
Hamilton and the F40: The Most Honest Financial Statement of the Ferrari Dream2026-09-03
Fernando Alonso and the 'Battery Championship' Battle - A Problem Beyond Aston Martin2026-09-04
F1 2026: The Race Has Already Begun in the Engine Lab2026-10-12
Hanoi 2026: When the Ball Rolled Through the Storm2026-09-03
Mercedes Holds ADUO Token, Antonelli Takes Grid Penalty at Monza2026-09-03
Bài đề xuất
Formula 1 2026: A Full Picture of the Biggest Regulatory Transition in More Than a Decade2026-10-08
Red Bull's 2026 Season: Valuing a Winless Team and the Narrow Door Called Madring2026-09-11
Ferrari at COTA: The Upgrade Restored Race Pace, but Q3 Remains the Crack2026-10-27
The F1 Analysis Machine and the Trap of an Empty Data Sheet2026-09-17
Lewis Hamilton criticizes Ferrari: Collision with Leclerc due to lack of clear rules2026-09-09
Monza: The Temple of Speed and the Cash-Flow Equation No Odds Board Reflects2026-09-03
Red Bull keep unchanged line-up at Monza: Hadjar’s injury opens a longer audition for Liam Lawson2026-09-03
Fernando Alonso and the 'Battery Championship' Battle - A Problem Beyond Aston Martin2026-09-04
