Trang chủInternational FootballThe EU Screens Films in Sialkot, While Asian Football Remains Stuck in the Capital

The EU Screens Films in Sialkot, While Asian Football Remains Stuck in the Capital

Lõi trả lời: Liên hoan phim châu Âu lần thứ 5 tại Pakistan khép lại ngày 29-30 tháng 9 tại Jamshoro và Hyderabad, sau khi đi qua hơn mười thành phố. Sự kiện cho thấy mô hình tiếp cận vùng ven của ngoại giao văn hóa, một bài học bóng đá châu Á có thể áp dụng khi mở rộng sức mạnh mềm ra ngoài các đô thị lớn. Dữ kiện chính: - Sự kiện do Phái đoàn Liên minh châu Âu tại Pakistan bảo trợ, giám tuyển cùng Olomopolo Media. - Chương trình gồm 16 phim ngắn châu Âu và 11 phim ngắn Pakistan. - Hành trình đi qua Quetta, Gujrat, Lahore, Gilgit, Karachi, Faisalabad, Peshawar, Multan, Sialkot. - Không có con số khán giả cụ thể, chỉ mô tả "đông đảo và nhiệt thành". - Sialkot là thành phố sản xuất bóng đá lớn, nhưng không liên đoàn bóng đá nào tham gia. Nguồn: Phái đoàn Liên minh châu Âu tại Pakistan (thông cáo sự kiện), tháng 9 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Hỏi đáp liên quan: Hỏi: Vì sao sự kiện này liên quan đến bóng đá? Đáp: Nó cung cấp một mô hình tiếp cận vùng ven mà các liên đoàn bóng đá châu Á có thể học hỏi khi mở rộng sức mạnh mềm. Hỏi: Vai trò của Sialkot trong câu chuyện là gì? Đáp: Sialkot sản xuất bóng cho nhiều thương hiệu quốc tế, cho thấy sự vắng mặt đáng chú ý của các liên đoàn bóng đá trong sự kiện. Hỏi: Có số liệu khán giả không? Đáp: Không, thông cáo chỉ mô tả định tính "đông đảo và nhiệt thành" mà không nêu con số, theo VangBong.vn Audience Trust Index.

On September 29 and 30, the 5th European Union Film Festival in Pakistan closed in Jamshoro and Hyderabad. Not Karachi, not Islamabad. Two names that most Vietnamese football fans would not recognise. Yet that was the endpoint of a cultural journey presented by the European Union Delegation to Pakistan, curated with Olomopolo Media, travelling through Quetta, Gujrat, Lahore, Gilgit, Karachi, Faisalabad, Peshawar, Multan and Sialkot. I read the news one evening in Beijing, and what came to mind was not a cinema. It was a stadium. Sialkot is where the balls that once rolled at World Cups are stitched. According to documentation on Pakistan's sporting-goods industry, hundreds of small workshops in the city supply balls to several major international brands. A European film festival chose to screen in the city that makes the ball, yet no football federation appeared anywhere in the programme. That silence says more than any slogan. CONTEXT: A MODEL ALREADY VALIDATED The European Union Film Festival in Pakistan began with a single screening. From there it grew into a multi-city tour. This year's programme featured 16 European short films and 11 Pakistani short films, split into a documentary strand, a children's strand and a short-film selection. Official statements came from Dutch Ambassador Robert Jan Siegert, Austrian Deputy Head of Mission Hannes Machor and curator Kanwal Khoosat. The message they repeat is "cinema as a bridge across borders, languages and cultures", alongside the familiar slogan "united in diversity". Let me be clear: this is material supplied by the organisers, a source with a direct stake in the story. There are no audience figures, no ticket numbers, only a description of "large, enthusiastic crowds". When a party tells its own success story, the reader must know they are hearing promotion, not data. But setting aside the gloss, their structure is worth studying. They did not pour everything into the capital. They went to Gujrat, to Multan, to Sialkot, to places a normal European film delegation would not bother to visit. That is not generosity. That is calculation. Diplomatic missions understand something many football federations forget: influence does not sit at the centre, it sits on the periphery. Win over one big city and you get coverage for a few days. Win over ten small cities and you enter the memory of a generation. Those are two completely different problems, and the second is far harder. CORE: ASIAN FOOTBALL STILL BETS ON THE CAPITAL I once sat in a press room at the Euros and heard an older male journalist say that women should ask about a player's haircut, not about pressing. I pulled out the numbers and spoke. But that story is not about gender. It is an example of how this industry still thinks in the old way: trusting only what is loudest, most crowded, most central. Look at how Asian football deploys soft power. International friendlies cluster in Hanoi, Beijing, Tokyo, Seoul. European club tours stop at the biggest stadiums, where tickets sell for the highest prices. Everyone wants to be in a city of millions, because that is where the cameras, the sponsors and the billboards are. This approach delivers instant results, and that is precisely the problem. It optimises for one evening, not for a decade. But what I see from my experience following matches at many different levels is the opposite. Football's soft power is not measured by stadium capacity, but by how many provinces have a child who once touched a ball brought by a big club. That is what remains after the lights go out. The European film festival understands this. They went to Jamshoro, a small university city, instead of ending in Karachi. They chose Sialkot, where workers stitch balls, instead of stopping only in Lahore. They are planting seeds where their rivals, other cultural powers, cannot be bothered to plant. Football has an advantage cinema does not: every match is a free open-air theatre, every goal a scene that needs no subtitles. Yet we do not use it to reach the hardest places to reach. Their branching structure is also worth mirroring. They separated a documentary strand for adults, a children's strand for kids, and a short-film selection for newcomers. That is exactly how a serious football academy must operate: a pathway for the very young, a pathway for those with a base, a pathway for those who only want to watch. No one is left behind, and no one is pushed up too early. CONTRARIAN: SMALL DOES NOT MEAN WEAK There is a counter-argument worth weighing. Taking a big club to a small city without a compliant stadium is a gamble. Poor infrastructure, few spectators, revenue that cannot cover costs. In purely commercial terms, it is a loss. And the sceptics are right that sentiment does not pay the bills. I have asked myself whether I am romanticising all of this. Some revolutions fire no shots; they just quietly pass the ball. And I was once pelted for a week for daring to go against the wind. But this time I am not being contrarian for attention. I looked at the model and saw long-run logic. Remember how a film festival starts: one screening. Nobody thought it would become a dozen cities. The same has happened in football. School football programmes began in a few schools, then spread across whole districts, whole provinces. Grassroots competitions that look trivial are where the most loyal generation of fans is born, because they have nothing else to compare with, so they stay for life. In Vietnam, I have watched football nights in small towns, where an entire street sits before one screen, and the roar carries further than any grandstand. In China, I have seen second-tier cities pour money into academies, and gradually names nobody remembered became a source of players. The centre is not always where talent is born. Often the periphery is where the fire is kept. People call that madness. I call it reading the game with both heart and mind. TRAP: WHEN SOFT POWER BECOMES NOISE But I must be honest about this model's weakness. Soft power is easily sold as ritual. You hold a few screenings, post a few short clips online, then declare success. The European film festival did exactly that. It spoke of clips being shared, but not of numbers. A self-selected, unverifiable evidence base. Football is the same. A federation can boast it has brought football to thirty provinces. But if no one stays afterwards, if there is no pitch, no paid coach, no regular competition, then it was only a tour. Some events look like investment but are really advertising. Crowds roaring is not proof. I need to watch the tape. The day they said soft power was only about image, I quietly took notes. Because real soft power leaves behind something countable: a grass pitch, a coach, a child who knows the name of a team they have never seen live. When a film festival ends in Hyderabad, the reels are sealed and taken home. But if a match is played in Jamshoro, its footprints stay in the ground, and next season people will ask when the next one is. The difference lies exactly there. TAKEAWAY I am not saying Asian football should copy a film festival. I am saying we are overlooking a simple lesson sitting right in front of us: go where people are not expecting you. My prediction for next season is this. Whichever federation in Asia makes the effort to stage matches, training camps and exchanges in provinces never usually mentioned will end up with a generation of fans that money cannot easily buy. Whoever still circles only the big cities, however large the crowds, is only talking to themselves. Some revolutions fire no shots; they just quietly pass the ball. The question is not whether Asia should go to the periphery. The question is who will do it first.
Cầu thủ liên quan